Let’s unpack a familiar scene: it’s Thursday evening. You’ve just plopped down on the couch after dinner. You’re totally wiped from a long week. Thank goodness tomorrow is Friday.
Choice paralysis means you take 20 minutes to decide what to put on Netflix, but it doesn’t matter, because approximately twelve seconds after hearing that Pavlovian tudum sound effect, you reflexively begin doomscrolling.
For those of us who regrettably choose X (the artist formerly known as Twitter, not the algebraic variable) as our favourite dopamine dealer, we’re likely to encounter a terribly frustrating, oddly irresistible vaguepost.
“can i say something without anyone getting mad?”
You know you shouldn’t investigate any further. Hell, you know you shouldn’t really care. Why devote a fraction of your valuable time to a hollow attempt at engagement baiting, perpetrated by a faceless stranger with the blue check veneer of importance?
Still… you engage.
Maybe comments from other users reveal pointless drama from some social media feud you don’t give two hoots about. Maybe there’s no answer at all, and the original tweeter simply makes off like a thief in the night with a few more Elon bucks lining their pockets.
Regardless of the truth behind the post, it’s rarely ever as interesting as the impulse that drove you to open it in the first place. There’s this weird human craving to uncover what’s happening, who said what, what came first, what comes next, what everything means.
The answer to that craving? Context.
If automobiles were never invented, how do you think you’d comprehend a red octagon with the word “STOP” written in the centre of it? Even the most transparent, function-forward, instruction-manual-level messaging requires a surrounding understanding of why it’s being communicated to you.
I know, hardly rocket science. The notion that communication without context loses meaning is fairly straightforward. Funnily enough, our machines know this too. AI models operate within context windows, using the information available within those windows to interpret what comes next. Human beings don’t have a literal token counter, but the principle is essentially the same.
And yet our visceral reaction to a phenomenon as innocuous as vagueposting suggests a more existential layer in this relationship. To put it bluntly, there’s something dread-inducing about how life itself seems to be losing context.
Consider a chasm between two hypothetical people. Person A and Person B live on opposite sides of the planet, one speaks Spanish and the other speaks Mandarin Chinese, and they grew up 30 years apart. Should these two individuals ever meet, the circumstances of their geographical, language, and generational gaps would naturally account for a significant communication barrier.
Now let’s erase that demographic distance.
I live in Toronto. I speak English. I was born in the early 90s. There are thousands of us within walking distance of each other who fit this exact same description… and I’d wager thousands of us who feel like we all have wildly different frames of reference.
Connor McDavid has been the best player in the NHL for the better part of a decade, but when I sarcastically describe my abysmal beer league hockey skills to an acquaintance as “I’m no McDavid,” I can hear the complete lack of recognition in his polite laugh. Surely he must be living under a rock, no?
Love Is Blind is one of the streaming era’s biggest unscripted hits, but when I overhear my coworkers using its iconic “pull you for a chat” phrase, I covertly Google the words to check if I’m forgetting a common euphemism. Surely I must be the one living under the rock…
So what accounts for this paradox? We should be circumstantial neighbors, right? Why are we experiencing cultural rifts as wide as the one separating our hypothetical Person A and Person B? Moreover, how much greater does this divide get when the niches that define us are, well, substantially more niche?
One potential answer to these questions is “the death of monoculture” — an oft-discussed buzzword (buzzconcept?) that positions the internet as Grim Reaper, eroding the very fabric of shared context. Personalized feeds, echo chamber algorithms, invite-only Discords, and a digital home for every fandom under the sun have simultaneously multiplied and narrowed our contextual borders.
For instance, as recently as the moment I publish this piece, there is continued public argument about Ella Langley’s country hit Choosin’ Texas. People who claim to have never even heard of the song are flabbergasted by its all-time record atop the Billboard Hot 100, while others disbelievingly deny that such a ubiquitous track could possibly fall on deaf ears.
We no longer need to live in different countries to live in different worlds. We no longer need to live on different planets to live in different universes.
At the heart of this seismic societal shift are two fascinating communication mutations:
1. Shared context can no longer be assumed
2. Our communication methods themselves are stripping away context
I’ve touched on the former, let’s delve into the latter.
It’s nearly midnight on Thursday now. You’re so deep into doomscrolling that Netflix is asking if you’re still there. As you swipe, you blitz through dozens of muted videos, opting to read rapidly-appearing captions rather than listen to — or even look at — the folks who deliver their latest sermons.
Perhaps the algorithm feeds you a standup comedian. Your attention sticks to the flashy subtitles, skimming an objectionable remark without hearing the performer’s affect or seeing their giddy smirk. You’re left with outrage. To unlearn this conclusion you’ve just jumped to, you’d have to unmute the video and investigate further. Who has the time for that?
And there it is: text has replaced speech. Tone, pacing, emphasis, facial expressions — clarifying communicative features, all discarded in favour of the literality of words. No wonder nuance has gone out of style.
Obviously there’s no debate that captions and subtitles are incredibly valuable tools. They allow us to engage in loud environments or situations where audio would disturb others. They help create an inclusive experience for those who are deaf or hard of hearing, neurodivergent, or sensitive to sound.
For me, the intrigue lies in how social platforms are repurposing these tools, reorienting their function and transforming them into primary pieces of consumption. This opens the door to the idea I find most potentially troublesome.
A few weeks ago, I was watching a social media snippet from a baseball game. The on-screen captions quoted the commentator as saying one thing, yet when I rewatched the video with the sound on, his exact phrase was slightly different. I suppose the meaning was similar enough, and it’s not like a misquote about the Blue Jays will end the world. On its face, it was just an innocent divergence, albeit one that shines a bright light on the parallel realities in which many of us now live…
Person A consumes the caption version, Person B consumes the audio version, and both walk away with a different understanding of what was said. So what about Person C, who, like me, watched both versions?
Days later, if Person C were to think back on the clip, they might recall the interpretive layer — the big, bold, colourful captions — more clearly than the monotonous tones of the commentator. The more accustomed Person C becomes to ingesting information through this layer, the easier it may become to remember the caption in place of the source material they already heard. Of course when that happens, interpretation is no longer interpretation; it’s the new source.
And there it is: I started this thought with an eye on how we’re losing context… turns out we can create whatever context we want.
Worrisome? Scary? Dangerous? If taken to an extreme, I think so. But though the medium might be new, and while the computers in our pockets might make it feel more pervasive, we’ve actually been creating context long before we were tweeting.
Jens Müller and Katharina Sussek authored The Elements of Brand Design, published by TASCHEN. A collection of case studies covering the logos, colours, and typography that define the companies you know and love, it’s another beautiful entry in TASCHEN’s chic catalogue of not-your-average coffee table books (and it was an excellent birthday present).
As I pored over the earnest and intentional thoughts behind every branding decision big and small, I realized that beyond aesthetics, these designers and agencies were hired for the express purpose of constructing context. Next time you pop into Uniqlo in search of a stylish pair of slacks, take note of how the vivid use of red throughout the store evokes the organization’s Japanese roots.
With every example Müller and Sussek presented, I gained a greater appreciation for the subtle art of it all. I was also reminded of my own filmmaking experience. Every camera angle, every cut, every element of every on-screen minute in my movies came from a choice I made, all intended to put the audience in a certain frame of mind.
Is creating context inherently corrupt? I suppose not, even if the scent of manipulation hangs in the air. Sometimes the purpose is nefarious engagement baiting; sometimes it’s making sure we safely pull our cars to a stop at the intersection. Maybe the more useful lesson is that whenever communication inevitably breaks down, words themselves aren’t always to blame. Before hastily rewriting or rephrasing, it may be worth taking a beat to determine if everyone involved is working from the same context.
Perhaps then we can finally find a way to say something without anyone getting mad.